Hiring a property manager in Jacksonville is mostly a question of fit. Some owners want someone local to take the late-night maintenance call, walk the home between tenants and handle the showings. Others are close enough, or comfortable enough, to run most of it themselves. The five companies below all manage single-family rentals in the Jacksonville area. For each one we've noted what they manage, where they work and what they publish about fees, so you can build a short list and start making calls. Most full-service managers charge a monthly percentage of rent plus a leasing fee, so ask every company for the full fee schedule in writing. Most of the percentage plans below are around 10% of monthly rent. On a $2,000 monthly rent, a 10% plan costs $200 a month. If you don't need a full-service manager, software like Nomad covers listing, screening and rent collection for about 4% of monthly rent, or about $80, plus a one-time $99 onboarding fee. When you'd rather not do the legwork, you can add Professional Tenant Placement to handle inquiries and tours, and send repairs to vetted Lula pros.

PMI River City is the Jacksonville office of Property Management Inc., a national franchise, and it's independently owned. It manages long-term residential rentals across Jacksonville, Orange Park, Middleburg, Ponte Vedra, St. Augustine and Yulee. The standard plan is 10% of monthly rent, a leasing fee of half a month's rent and a $125 renewal fee. Homes renting for $3,000 or more have a separate plan. If they don't place a tenant within 21 days, the first month's management fee is waived, and a tenant who leaves before 12 months is replaced at no charge (conditions apply). A good fit if you want published pricing and written guarantees.
Nest Finders is a locally owned Jacksonville company that has managed rentals since the mid-2000s. It covers the city plus Ponte Vedra Beach, St. Augustine, St. Johns, Nocatee and the beaches. Owners can choose 10% of monthly rent ($150 minimum) or a flat $239 a month, either with a placement fee of 75% of one month's rent. Its leasing guarantee replaces a tenant who leaves before nine months, and it offers an eviction guarantee and a pet damage guarantee on tenants it places. Listings get 3D virtual tours, and you can cancel any time with 30 days' notice.
Green River manages rental homes across the First Coast from offices in Jacksonville, Fleming Island and Ponte Vedra. It's one of the few local firms with a flat-fee plan: $115 a month on its Silver plan, with percentage plans at 10% and 12% for more included service. Placement fees run from 50% to 100% of a month's rent depending on the plan, and renewals are 25%. If your home isn't leased within 30 days, the next month of management is free. Pet damage is covered beyond the deposit, up to a limit that depends on the plan. A good fit if you want predictable monthly costs.
Red Rooster is a small, independent firm serving Jacksonville and northwest St. Johns County, run by a broker-owner who is a U.S. Navy veteran. Its pricing is published and unusually flexible: a $195 flat monthly plan for homes renting at $2,000 or more, or percentage plans from 8.9% to 14.9% of rent. The top tier includes leasing and maintenance coordination with no separate fees. Owners get 24/7 access to an online portal. A good fit if you'd rather work directly with the person running the company.
Keyrenter Jacksonville is a locally owned franchise of Keyrenter, a national property management brand. It covers Jacksonville, Mandarin, the beaches, Ponte Vedra, Nocatee, Palm Valley and Fernandina Beach. Full service is 10% of monthly rent plus a leasing fee of one month's rent, with discounts for owners with several homes. If they don't find a tenant within 30 days, the first month's management fee is waived (conditions apply). There's no long-term contract: you can cancel with 30 days' notice.


The Nomad Difference
With Guaranteed Rent, you're paid on a set schedule each month of the lease term, even when your tenant pays late. Nomad works with the tenant to collect. Terms apply.


Unlocking economic opportunity for everyone.
Already a customer with us? Login to your portal

© 2026 Nomad Labs, Inc. All rights reserved.
Nomad Brokerage LLC
Nomad Brokerage California Inc
California DRE # 02230490
Texas Real Estate Commission Consumer Protection NoticeTexas Real Estate Commission Information about Brokerage Services