Why NomadPricing

Nomad Blog

Back to all posts

How to Convert a Short-Term Rental to a Long-Term Rental

Last updated on: Nov 10, 2026

Published on: Feb 1, 2024

Hero Image

Running a short-term rental can pay well, but the work needed to maintain a quality place to stay can easily take over your life. Turnovers, guest messages, restocking, cleaners who cancel, reviews, and city rules that keep changing. It adds up. Plenty of owners who started on Airbnb or Vrbo reach a point where converting their short-term rental to a long-term rental, with one tenant on a 12-month lease, sounds better than a new guest every few nights.

This guide is for property owners who are considering what it might look like to convert their rental. First, we'll walk through how to tell whether the switch makes sense financially. Then, we'll cover how to get the home ready, close out permits, switch insurance, handle taxes, and find and screen a long-term tenant. The good news: going from short-term to long-term is usually simpler than the other way around.

Leasing to a tenant works differently from hosting guests. If this is your first long-term lease, our guide to renting out your house for the first time explains how it runs from listing to move-in.

Note: This article is general information, not legal, tax, or insurance advice. Short-term rental rules are set city by city and change often, and tax treatment depends on your situation. Check your local rules and talk to a tax professional and a licensed insurance agent before you switch.

Converting a short-term rental to a long-term rental at a glance

  • Run the numbers on a full year: compare your last 12 months of short-term net income with a realistic long-term rent, after every cost on both sides and a few weeks of vacancy for the switch.

  • Pick a cutoff date: block your calendars past your last confirmed booking on every platform, the same day you decide.

  • Decide furnished or unfurnished: furnished homes can earn a little more rent but usually take longer to lease.

  • Price off long-term comparables: your nightly rate tells you little about monthly rent.

  • Wind down the paperwork: short-term rental permits, lodging tax accounts, and any long-term rental license your city requires.

  • Switch insurance and check taxes: a short-term rental policy and a landlord policy cover different things, and the IRS treats short stays and 12-month leases differently.

  • Screen like a landlord: a long-term tenant needs income, credit, and rental history checks that guest reviews can't replace.

Why owners convert a short-term rental to a long-term rental

A long-term rental is a home leased to one tenant for 12 months or more, under landlord-tenant law rather than short-term rental rules. Owners move a home from Airbnb or Vrbo to a long-term lease for a few common reasons, and usually more than one at once.

  • Time. A short-term rental is a hospitality business. Every stay means a turnover, a cleaning, supplies, check-in messages, and a review to manage. A long-term rental has one tenant, one lease, and a turnover every year or two.

  • Steadier income. Short-term revenue swings with the season, local events, and travel demand. A 12-month lease replaces that with one monthly rent payment, though a tenant can still end up paying late or not at all.

  • More competition. In some markets, more homes have joined Airbnb and Vrbo, which can push nightly rates and occupancy down.

  • Management costs. If you pay a short-term rental manager, the fee is usually a bigger share of income than long-term management, where fees of 10% of rent or more are common for a traditional property manager. Hostfully's April 2026 guide to short-term rental management fees puts most managers between 15% and 30% of income.

  • Expenses you stop paying. In a typical long-term lease, the tenant pays some or all of the utilities, and you stop paying for internet, streaming, linens, toiletries, and restocking.

  • Local rules. Many cities limit where short-term rentals are allowed, require a license, cap the number of permits, or limit them to the owner's primary residence. A rule change can make the switch for you.

  • Wear and tear. Hundreds of guest check-ins a year are hard on floors, furniture, and fixtures. A long-term tenant still causes normal wear, just at a slower pace.

A short-term rental is still the right fit for some homes and some owners, especially in strong tourist markets where you enjoy the work or have a good local team. The decision comes down to your numbers and how you want to spend your time.

Airbnb vs. long-term rental: compare the numbers

The fairest way to compare an Airbnb with a long-term rental is to put a full year of each side by side, net of every cost. Use your actual short-term results for the last 12 months, not your best month, and an honest estimate of long-term rent based on similar homes that leased nearby.

Side-by-side worksheet

Line item

Short-term rental (last 12 months)

Long-term rental (next 12 months)

Gross income

Total booking revenue from your platform earnings or payout reports, plus any direct bookings

Monthly rent × 12

Vacancy

Already reflected in your actual bookings

A few weeks to a couple of months for the switch, plus an allowance for future turnovers

Platform and booking fees

Service fees and payment fees shown on your payout reports

Listing and leasing costs, if any

Management

Short-term manager or co-host fees

Software or property manager fees, if you use them

Cleaning and turnover

Cleaner pay minus the cleaning fees guests paid

One move-out clean and touch-up per turnover

Utilities and services

Electricity, gas, water, trash, internet, streaming

Only the utilities your lease leaves with you

Supplies and furnishings

Toiletries, linens, kitchen items, furniture

None if unfurnished; repairs and replacements if furnished

Taxes and licenses

Short-term rental permit and license fees, time spent on lodging tax filings

Any long-term rental license or registration fee

Insurance

Short-term rental policy

Landlord policy

Repairs and maintenance

Your actual repair spending

A set monthly amount for repairs

Mortgage, property tax, HOA

Same on both sides

Same on both sides

Your time

Hours per month on guests, cleaners, and listings

Hours per month on one tenant

Lodging and occupancy taxes that guests pay through the platform usually pass straight through, so leave them out of income on both sides. Count the time it takes you to file them, though.

Budget for the gap between your last guest and your first tenant. Across 67 markets, houses spent about two months on the market on average over the past year, from about one month in Cheyenne, Wyoming, to more than four months in Hawaii (Zillow Rentals data compiled by Nomad, November 2025 to October 2026). Your own market's number is a better guide than the national one, and a well-priced, well-presented home often leases faster than average.

If the two columns come out close, your time usually decides it. If the short-term column wins by a wide margin and you like the work, the switch may not be worth it yet. Our guide to the costs that eat into rental profits has more on the expense lines.

If you list with Nomad, you'll see a rent estimate for your home to use in the long-term column. You still set the rent.

Prepare the home for a long-term tenant

A home set up for short stays needs some changes before it works for someone who will live there for a year.

Empty living room with hardwood floors ready for a long-term tenant.”

Furnished or unfurnished

Most long-term renters bring their own furniture, so a former short-term rental can often lease faster when empty, depending on market conditions. Nomad's 2025 analysis of its own long-term listings found furnished homes rented for slightly more than unfurnished ones but took longer to lease: 34 days on market on average versus 27 (Nomad leasing data, 2025). 

That leaves three practical options for your furniture:

  • Sell or donate it and lease the home unfurnished, which reaches the largest pool of renters.

  • Store it if you might return to short-term renting later. Weigh the storage cost against what the furniture is worth.

  • Keep it and lease furnished, or partly furnished, if your area has steady demand from renters relocating for work or on temporary assignments. The mid-term option below covers this.

Our breakdown of furnished vs. unfurnished rentals has the full numbers.

Change what a guest needed into what a tenant needs

  • Clear the storage. Owner's closets, locked cabinets, and supply rooms make sense for short stays. A tenant will likely want access to all storage space in the unit. 

  • Remove guest supplies: toiletries, extra linens, welcome baskets, and the house manual written for guests.

  • Check the basics renters look for, such as laundry hookups or a washer and dryer, enough storage, and working window coverings.

  • Reset smart devices. Change keypad codes, reset smart locks and thermostats, and remove any noise monitors or cameras you used for guest stays, including outdoor ones a tenant could see as intrusive.

  • Fix the wear. Touch up paint, repair scuffed floors, and service the HVAC so you start the lease with fewer repair calls. Our list of budget-friendly rental upgrades covers what's worth doing.

  • Document the condition. Take dated photos of every room before move-in. They'll matter when you return the security deposit.

New photos and a new listing

Your short-term listing photos sell a getaway: styled beds, a set table, a view. Long-term renters want to see room sizes, storage, the kitchen, the laundry, and the yard. Retake photos once the home is set up the way you'll lease it, and write the listing around what matters for living there, such as commute, schools, parking, and which utilities the tenant pays. 

Our guide to rental listing photos explains what to shoot. If you lease with Nomad, owners can choose to have professional photos taken for $189, with the cost returned in the first month of your lease.

Price it off long-term comparables

Your nightly rate tells you little about monthly rent. Price the home against similar long-term rentals nearby that leased recently, adjusting for size, condition, parking, and laundry. If you lease furnished, compare it with other furnished long-term rentals, not with unfurnished ones. Our guide to pricing a rental property walks through it step by step.

If you list with Nomad, your listing goes out to 30+ rental sites, and you choose how much of the showing work to keep: reply to renters and host tours yourself, or let verified renters tour on their own with a lockbox. You decide the asking rent and any changes to it.

Wind down your short-term rental calendars and permits

Converting a short-term rental to a long-term rental means closing out the short-term side in a set order, so you don't end up with a guest booked the week your tenant moves in.

Block your calendars and handle existing bookings

  • Pick a cutoff date after your last confirmed booking, and leave time after it for cleaning, repairs, and photos. We recommend a week or two at a minimum.

  • Block every date past the cutoff on every platform the home is listed on, plus your direct booking site and any channel manager that syncs them.

  • Keep your existing bookings where you can. Canceling a confirmed reservation usually costs you. Airbnb's host cancellation policy for homes, for example, charges hosts 10% of the reservation amount when they cancel more than 30 days before check-in, 25% between 48 hours and 30 days, and 50% within 48 hours, with a minimum fee of $50. Canceling can also block those dates and affect your listing (Airbnb Help Center, checked October 30, 2026). Other platforms set their own rules, so check each one.

  • Unlist or deactivate the listing once the last guest checks out.

  • Cancel short-term services: cleaners, restocking, co-hosts, channel managers, guest messaging tools, and the internet and streaming accounts in your name, unless your lease keeps them with you.

You can start showing the home to long-term renters before the last guest leaves, as long as tours fit between stays. Set the lease start date after your cutoff.

Close out permits, licenses, and lodging taxes

Short-term rental rules are local, so start with your city or county's short-term rental office and your state revenue department.

  • Short-term rental permit or license: find out whether you need to surrender it or can let it lapse. In cities that cap permits, a lapsed permit may be hard to get back, so ask before you give it up if you might return to short-term renting.

  • Lodging and occupancy tax accounts: file your final returns for the last stays and close the accounts, so you don't get notices for missed filings later.

  • Long-term rental license or registration: some cities require a separate license for long-term rentals. Denver, for example, defines a short-term rental as a home rented for 1 to 29 days, and requires a residential rental property license if you only rent for 30-plus days at a time (City and County of Denver, checked October 30, 2026).

  • HOA rules: check for lease minimums, tenant registration, or move-in fees.

  • Landlord-tenant law: a 12-month tenant has rights a guest doesn't, from security deposit limits to notice before entry. Our guide to security deposit limits and deadlines by state is a good place to start.

If you list with Nomad, the lease is built for your state and market, and you can customize and review it before anyone signs.

Switch your insurance

Short-term rental insurance and landlord insurance cover different risks, so plan the change with your agent before your first tenant moves in. A policy written for nightly guests may not fit a 12-month tenancy, and a standard landlord policy may not cover nightly stays, so the timing of the switch matters.

Questions to ask your licensed agent:

  • Which policy covers the home between the last guest and the first tenant, while it sits empty?

  • Can the landlord policy start on the lease start date, with no gap?

  • Which landlord policy form is this (DP-1, DP-2, or DP-3), and what does it cover?

  • Does it include loss of rent coverage if the home can't be lived in after a covered loss?

  • If I lease furnished, how much coverage is there for my furniture and appliances?

  • What liability limit makes sense for a long-term rental?

Our guide to landlord insurance vs. homeowners insurance explains the policy types.

How Nomad handles this: You can get a landlord insurance quote from Nomad's partner, Steadily, when you're ready to switch policies.

Taxes when a short-term rental becomes a long-term rental

The IRS treats short stays and 12-month leases differently, so the switch can change how you report the income. This is a high-level overview; ask a tax professional how it applies to you.

  • Where you report it. If you provide substantial services primarily for guests' convenience, such as regular cleaning, changing linens, or maid service, IRS Publication 527 says you report the income on Schedule C and may owe self-employment tax. A long-term rental without those services is generally reported on Schedule E.

  • Passive activity rules. Under IRS Publication 925, an activity where the average guest stay is 7 days or less isn't treated as a rental activity for the passive activity rules. A 12-month lease is a rental activity, which changes how losses can be used, including the special allowance of up to $25,000 for owners who actively participate, which phases out at higher incomes. If you've been using short-term rental losses to offset other income, ask your tax professional how the switch affects that.

  • Personal use. If you stayed in the home yourself for more than 14 days, or more than 10% of the days it was rented at a fair price, Publication 527 treats it as used as a home and limits your deductions. Once it's leased year-round, you won't have personal-use days to track.

  • Furniture. Furniture used in a residential rental is depreciated over 5 years under Publication 527. If you sell, store, or keep the furniture, ask your tax professional how to handle what's left of its basis. If you took bonus depreciation on it, there may be little or none left.

  • Lodging taxes. Lodging and occupancy taxes are aimed at short stays. Once the home is on a 12-month lease, confirm with your city and state that you have no further filings, since each sets its own cutoff.

Our guide to rental property tax deductions covers what you can deduct as a long-term landlord.

Moving boxes labeled for the kitchen in a long-term rental.

Find and screen a long-term tenant

Choosing a tenant is a bigger decision than accepting a guest for a few days. A guest's reviews tell you how they treat a home for a weekend. A tenant will live there for a year or more, so you’ll need to know that they can pay the rent each month and that they’re someone you can trust to respect your property.

  • Write your screening criteria first (minimum income, credit, rental history) and apply them the same way to every applicant. Consistent criteria are what fair housing rules expect.

  • Verify income with pay stubs, offer letters, or bank statements.

  • Check rental history by calling past landlords. A guest profile isn't a reference.

  • Confirm identity to guard against application fraud.

  • Set the lease term and end date on purpose. A 12-month lease is standard. If that would end in winter, consider a slightly longer first lease so it ends during the busier spring and summer leasing months. Our post on lease end dates explains why.

Our guide to tenant screening covers each check in detail.

How Nomad handles this: If you list with Nomad, every applicant goes through a 10-point screen covering credit, income, identity, and background where the law allows, and you choose who gets the lease.

The middle option: furnished mid-term rentals

A mid-term rental is a furnished home rented for a month or more at a time, usually 1 to 6 months, often to people relocating for work, on a temporary assignment, or between homes. For a former Airbnb, it can be a middle step: the furniture stays, turnovers drop from weekly to every few months, and in some cities stays of 30 days or more fall outside the short-term rental rules.

Furnished bedroom set up for a mid-term rental.

Short-term rental

Mid-term rental

Long-term rental

Typical stay

A few nights to a few weeks

About 1 to 6 months

12 months or more

Furnishing

Fully furnished and stocked

Furnished

Usually unfurnished

Turnovers

Every stay

Several a year

Every year or two

Local rules

Often permits, caps, and lodging taxes

Depends on how your city and state define short-term and tenancy

Landlord-tenant law and any rental license

Your time

Highest

Medium

Lowest

Before you choose mid-term, check two things. First, how your city defines a short-term rental, since the cutoff isn't always 30 days. Second, how your state treats someone who stays a month or more, because in some states a long enough stay gives the occupant tenant rights, including the right to formal notice before they have to leave. Make sure your insurance covers furnished stays of that length, too.

If you list with Nomad, you can lease the home furnished on a long-term lease and set the rent to reflect the furniture.

Frequently asked questions

Can I convert my Airbnb into a long-term rental?

Yes. Pick a cutoff date after your last confirmed booking, block your calendars past it, close out your short-term rental permit and lodging tax accounts, switch to a landlord insurance policy, then price, list, and screen for a long-term tenant. Check whether your city requires a separate license for long-term rentals.

Is a long-term rental more profitable than an Airbnb?

A long-term rental is more profitable than an Airbnb when its rent, after costs and vacancy, comes close to or beats your short-term net income for a full year. Short-term rentals often earn more gross revenue, but fees, cleaning, supplies, utilities, and management take a bigger share. Compare a full 12 months of each, net of every cost, and count your time.

What is a mid-term rental?

A mid-term rental is a furnished home rented for a month or more at a time, usually 1 to 6 months, to renters such as people relocating for work or on temporary assignments. It sits between a short-term rental and a 12-month lease in turnover, income, and time.

Do I have to cancel my Airbnb reservations to switch to a long-term rental?

No. You can keep your confirmed bookings, block every date after the last one, and set the lease start after your cutoff. Canceling confirmed reservations usually brings host fees and other penalties on Airbnb, and other platforms have their own rules.

Should I rent my former Airbnb furnished or unfurnished?

Unfurnished usually leases faster to a larger pool of renters. Nomad's 2025 listing data shows furnished long-term rentals earning a small rent premium but taking longer to lease, so furnished makes most sense where demand from relocating or temporary renters is steady.

How long does it take to find a long-term tenant?

Plan for a few weeks to a couple of months. Across 67 markets, houses spent about two months on the market on average over the past year, from about one month in Cheyenne, Wyoming, to more than four months in Hawaii (Zillow Rentals data compiled by Nomad, November 2025 to October 2026). A home priced off long-term comparables, with photos retaken for long-term renters, often leases faster than average.

Do I need different insurance for a long-term rental?

Yes, in most cases. A short-term rental policy and a landlord policy are written for different risks, so ask your licensed agent to quote a landlord policy that starts on the lease start date and confirm how the home is covered while it sits empty between guests and tenants.

New Heights Buffaloes

Reach New Heights

Get a no-obligation estimate for Guaranteed Rent, and see how Nomad can help you earn more with less stress

Nomad Buffalo
Logo

Unlocking economic opportunity for everyone.

Help centerThe Nomad blogAboutCareersPrivacy policy
California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) Opt-Out Icon
Your privacy choices

Already a customer with us? Login to your portal

Equal Housing Logo

© 2026 Nomad Labs, Inc. All rights reserved.

Nomad Brokerage LLC

Nomad Brokerage California Inc

California DRE # 02230490

Texas Real Estate Commission Consumer Protection NoticeTexas Real Estate Commission Information about Brokerage Services
Chatbot bubble